Izhar
Saturday, November 14, 2026
More Top Math Films Review
Saturday, November 7, 2026
Pro-D Day Alternative: Mathematics in the Age of AI
On October 31, I joined an online seminar titled Mathematics in the Age of AI, delivered by Dr. Hamza Waseem (Syracuse University, London, and the Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford) for the National STEM School in Pakistan. The audience was students aged 15 to 18. Teenagers are rarely invited to such conversations, even though, as Dr. Waseem observed afterward, “they are the very ones who will inherit a completely new mathematical ecosystem by the time they reach university.” Over one afternoon, we explored what mathematics really is, how and why we do it, and what schools often get wrong about teaching it. We also weighed the looming prospects and dangers of AI. Dr. Waseem called the session “cathartic,” and I left feeling the same. I also left with a renewed conviction that mathematics is a profoundly human activity, a shared heritage that we, as future teachers, are responsible for protecting.
What mathematics really is
Following David Bessis’s Mathematica, Dr. Waseem drew mathematics as a loop. On one side is official maths (logic): proofs, axioms, calculation. On the other is secret maths (intuition): dreaming, feeling, guessing. Each feeds the other. Grothendieck could not read a mathematical text unless it aroused “mental images, intuitions that will give it life,” and Einstein said conventional words came only “in a secondary stage.” Bill Thurston’s classic essay On Proof and Progress in Mathematics (1994), which heads the earlier readings on Dr. Waseem’s reading list, asked not how mathematicians prove theorems but how they advance human understanding. Reuben Hersh’s 18 Unconventional Essays on the Nature of Mathematics goes further: mathematics is a human, social and cultural activity, not a set of truths floating somewhere outside us. On this view, a proof is the evidence that understanding happened, and understanding happens in a person.
How and why we do it
We do mathematics by moving around Dr. Waseem’s second loop: problem-solving feeds understanding, and understanding feeds problem-solving. His own journey began in 2008 with a Kangaroo competition certificate urging him to “continue training in problem solving.” The why matters most. G. H. Hardy called the mathematician “a maker of patterns,” like a painter or a poet, and Francis Su, whose essay “Love of Humanity Is Not Enough” is on the list, argues in Mathematics for Human Flourishing that we do mathematics because it meets deep human desires for play, beauty, truth, justice, and love.
What schools often get wrong
Bessis’s essay “The Fall of the Theorem Economy” gave me the sharpest lens. Research mathematics has long rewarded theorems as a proxy for understanding. That proxy worked because no human could prove something without first understanding it, and AI has broken that link. Schools run their own version, an answer economy, in which correct answers and grades stand in for understanding. Students learned long ago that this proxy can be gamed, first with memorized procedures and now with a chatbot. Paul Lockhart’s A Mathematician’s Lament reminds us that mathematics is an art, yet we teach only its official half. If school mathematics means producing answers, the machine has already won. What the machine cannot replace is the student who notices a pattern, makes a bold conjecture, is wrong, and finds out why. Grant Sanderson’s guest essay on Terence Tao’s blog, “If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate the rest of it,” proposes rewarding great explanations as seriously as great proofs. Classrooms can do the same by grading explanations, not just answers.
The looming prospects and dangers of AI
The list deliberately holds both moods. On the hopeful side are Daniel Litt’s “A beginning for mathematics,” Stefano Gogioso’s “Why I am excited, as opposed to frightened,” and Sanderson’s video “There’s never been a better time to go into math.” An AI can be a tireless sparring partner, example-generator, and proof-checker in Lean. On the other hand, the 722 machine-written papers OpenAI released on October 6 remain largely unverified: three were retracted within a day, and some formal proofs established weaker results than their papers claimed. In September, 25 Fields Medalists, including Tao, Scholze, and Viazovska, endorsed the declaration “A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics (https://mathandai.org/)”, warning that “solving problems is only a tool and proxy for achieving the primary goal of conceptual understanding and insight.” In a classroom, the quieter danger is a student who hands the whole loop to a machine and gets answers without ever being changed by them.
Our shared heritage, and what we must protect
“We participate in a millenary tradition,” writes Amar Hadzihasanovic in one of the short pieces on the list. That tradition runs from Babylonian clay tablets, through Euclid, Brahmagupta’s zero and al-Khwārizmī’s al-jabr, to a student in Surrey sketching a parabola today. It is our common inheritance across cultures. As Henry Wilton warned, authorless papers risk implying that mathematics is “no longer a human endeavour.” Chess offers some hope: computers have beaten world champions for decades, yet more people play chess than ever, because the point was always the human playing. Kevin Buzzard asks whether “to grieve, or not to grieve?” For a teacher, the answer is to teach. Dr. Waseem closed by asking what a student must aspire to, and I take that as my design brief. My answer is understanding. That means estimating and conjecturing before calculating, asking “why?” as often as “what?”, celebrating thoughtful wrong guesses, and using AI to sharpen intuition rather than replace it. The machines may write the theorems; our job is to make sure people still understand them. Progress in Maths means human understanding, not just an answer, because learning has never been only about the answer; it’s the process, it’s the struggle, it’s the mistakes, it’s the moment that it finally clicks, and we finally call, ‘Aha!’ That’s where the love of learning happens.
Monday, October 26, 2026
Group Micro-teaching Reflection
On Wednesday, October 21, Adam, Jarrad, Joe, and I taught a 15-minute Grade 8 lesson on theoretical probability to half of our EDCP 342A class. We built the lesson around two class activities, including one carnival game, “The Lucky Double”: pay $1, flip heads AND roll a 6, win $10, and another game involving rolling three dice at a time to find the probability of a particular sum across all three dice. After a brief introduction, the lesson started with “Which game would you like to play?” to divide the students in half, and every part of the lesson after that was designed to give students the math to answer. Eleven classmates gave us written feedback, and we also assessed ourselves. Here is what I learned.
Average peer ratings (out of 3, from 11 classmates)What went well
Engagement was our biggest strength. Most ratings for focus, confidence and body language were the top score of 3. Classmates wrote “Very interactive, very cool!”, “Really great lesson! So fun!” and “Loved the carnival games theme!” The hands-on Booth Lab, where pairs flipped coins and rolled dice, worked especially well; one peer said it “gets students going”. I was also glad the math came through. One classmate thought there could be “no way” for content this complicated to be clear, “but it is clear, and even has a lab”. Another noted our “concrete distinction between theoretical and actual probability”, and a third left knowing that “probability is not obvious”. For Grade 8, that is a powerful idea.
What did not go to plan
Honestly, our biggest problem started before we taught. Because we had so little time to meet either virtually or in-person, there was a lack of communication and coordination while we prepared. Each of us built a strong part on our own, but no one owned the full 15 minutes. Together we prepared more material and activities than a 15-minute lesson can hold: 15 slides, a hook video, a lab, two practice problems, and a fair-game challenge. On the day, time management became our main issue. We ran out of time, and our conclusion was too short. Timing received our second-lowest score, including a 1 with the note “Try to conclude in time” and the comment “you tried to cover a lot in 15 minutes”.
Losing the ending hurt more than I expected. Our lesson was a story that began with “Which game would you like to play?” and was meant to end by solving the booth: a 1/12 chance of winning, so the booth keeps about 17¢ of every dollar. Without that ending, the story had no payoff. I think this is why “learning objectives met” was our lowest score, why one peer “lost track of the learning objective along the way”. Our own self-assessments agreed: we had fun, but we were not sure the objectives were fully met. Two more comments made me think. Classmates suggested we could build on earlier learning (“as we saw last class”) instead of re-teaching every term. And one warned, half-joking, “Be careful turning kids into gamblers!” A money game is a great hook, but I must frame it as a lesson about how games are designed so the house wins, not as an invitation to play.
In my own part, Four Ways to See a Sample Space, I explained set notation and a tree diagram and showed a table and a Venn diagram in under four minutes. Looking back, that was a lot. The curriculum names tree diagrams and tables; teaching those two deeply while saving the set notation and Venn diagram for another day might have taught more.
- Plan less, teach deeper. A short lesson needs one clear goal. I will sort content into “must know” and “nice to have” and keep the second as an extension.
- Protect the closure. When time runs short, cut from the middle, never from the end. The closing is where learning comes together.
- Rehearse with a timer. One full run-through would have shown us the problem before our classmates did.
- Communicate early when co-teaching. Agree on the objective and the timing first, then build one shared plan with one timekeeper.
- Keep the objective visible. Return to it during the lesson and bring the whole class together to discuss problems, as one peer suggested.
Tuesday, October 20, 2026
Saturday, October 17, 2026
Individual Micro-teaching Reflection

- Frame before showing. One peer suggested explaining the video a little before playing it, and another asked for “more of an overview at the start”. These two comments point to the same lesson. I knew what the video was for, so it felt obvious to me, but my learners did not. One sentence, such as “Watch the player, count the corners, and be ready to shout the next one,” would have turned a surprise into a purpose.
- Invite questions. A peer reminded me to “ask if there are any questions”. In a tight ten minutes, I kept moving forward and forgot to stop and invite the learners in. A question check is not lost time; it is the moment I find out what they actually understood.
- Protect practice time. In my own self-assessment, I gave myself a 2 for timing and pacing. My plan gave two minutes to student practice, but explanation and demonstration ran long, so practice felt short. Skills are learned by doing, not by watching the teacher do.
- A hook needs a frame. A great visual is powerful only when learners know what to look for. Before I show a graph, a pattern, or a video, I will tell students what question it helps answer.
- Plan in minutes, and know what to cut. Next time, I will mark which parts of my plan can shrink if I run late, so practice never gets squeezed.
- Pause on purpose. I will build a “What questions do you have?” moment into every lesson plan instead of leaving it to chance.
Thursday, October 15, 2026
Monday, October 12, 2026
Feedback To Malihe on Her Workshop on Iranian Immigrant Math Students
Malihe opened her talk with a question I did not expect: what happens when a Canadian family moves to Iran and tries to enrol their child in school, or find a sport or music teacher? As we imagined it, the difficulties piled up quickly: application forms in an unfamiliar script, a different calendar, unwritten rules about who to ask and how. Then Malihe turned the question around, and that shift in perspective was the most valuable part of the session for me. An Iranian family arriving in BC faces the same disorientation in reverse. Parents must make sense of catchment areas, online registration, transcripts that need translating and dates written in the Persian calendar, and a grade placement that may not match what their child had completed at home. Even a report card can be confusing, because a family used to marks out of 20 now receives descriptive proficiency scales. None of this is a problem of ability; it is a problem of navigating a system whose logic is invisible to newcomers.
For the students themselves, the differences reach right into the mathematics. Many Iranian students arrive with strong procedural skills, built in a centralized, exam-focused system that values speed, accuracy and practice, and they then meet a BC curriculum that asks them to explain their thinking, work in groups and investigate open-ended problems. Language adds another layer. Persian is written from right to left while numbers run left to right, Persian digits look different, and the Persian decimal separator resembles a slash, so a number like 2.5 can be confused with a fraction. A student may still do mental arithmetic in Persian while being asked to justify their reasoning in English. Even “real-life” word problems are not culturally neutral: a question about hockey statistics or Thanksgiving recipes assumes everyday knowledge that a newcomer may not yet have, so the real difficulty can be the context rather than the mathematics.
Malihe’s grounding of her research in cultural sustainability and social justice helped me see these challenges as questions of equity, not just adjustment. When newcomer students, whether from Iran, Afghanistan, Syria, Ukraine or elsewhere, are placed in lower math courses because of their English, or judged by their unfamiliarity with classroom discussion, the system can quietly turn a language difference into a mathematics deficit. That label can follow them for years and narrow the pathways open to them. Social justice education asks us to notice whose knowledge counts in our classrooms and to remove barriers rather than expect students to overcome them alone. In mathematics, that means assessing understanding separately from English fluency and making sure that being new to Canada never limits how far a student can go.
What I take from Malihe’s talk is that a newcomer student’s struggle in math class is often a mismatch of systems rather than a gap in understanding. As a future teacher, I want to treat students’ first languages and earlier methods as resources: invite them to show how they learned a procedure, allow them to think in Persian before explaining in English, check notation before assuming an error, and choose real-life contexts that draw on students’ own experiences. I also want to communicate with parents in ways that make the BC system visible rather than assumed. Thank you, Malihe, for helping us see our future classrooms through the eyes of the families who are newest to them.
More Top Math Films Review
Anthony Persico’s Mashup Math list, “10 Best Math Movies for All Ages,” suggests these films as a break from tests or some Friday fun. I thi...
-
Hi everyone, and happy start to your BEd. Looking forward to learning from and with you all. ...
-
Malihe opened her talk with a question I did not expect: what happens when a Canadian family moves to Iran and tries to enrol their child in...
-
The first thing that made me stop was not an argument but a child’s reply: “Of course I do. Look, I’ve got all these answers right.” I have...






