The first thing that made me stop was not an argument but a child’s reply: “Of course I do. Look, I’ve got all these answers right.” I have heard that sentence many times, in English and in Urdu. When a student in Pakistan told me “samajh aa gaya” (“I’ve understood”), I rarely questioned it, because the school board examination asked the kinds of questions the textbook had already trained them for. Skemp’s idea of faux amis showed me that my students and I were using one word for two different things. More uncomfortably, I had once been one of those students. My own schooling rewarded faithfully reproducing a solved example, and for years I thought I understood mathematics because I could perform it.
The second thing that stopped me was the head of mathematics, who told his class to write their answers “exactly like the example in the book.” I smiled at first, then recognized the move. When a marking scheme decides grades, and the syllabus must be “covered” before exams, the model answer quietly becomes the curriculum. Skemp’s line, “nothing else but relational understanding can ever be adequate for a teacher,” names a cycle I know well. Teachers who were taught instrumentally go on to teach instrumentally. This is not laziness. Instrumental understanding is simply all the system ever asked of them.
The third moment, and the one that has stayed with me most, was Skemp’s image of the town: a walker following fixed plans and a walker building a mental map. From the outside, he says, the two look identical. That is exactly why an exam script cannot tell you which kind of learner wrote it. I saw the difference most clearly while teaching programming rather than mathematics. Students who had memorized a loop or a recursive function could reproduce it perfectly. But the moment the program threw an error, they were lost, because a fixed plan offers no way back after a wrong turn. Students who had a map treated the programming bug as information: they knew where they were, so they could work out what had gone wrong. I now think debugging may be the purest everyday test of relational understanding. Discrete mathematics showed me the same thing. A student who has learned proof by induction as a three-step template can prove that 1 + 2 + … + n = n (n + 1)/2. Yet the same student freezes when induction is applied to an inequality or a graph, because the template told them what to write and never why the dominoes fall.
So where do I stand? With Skemp, but with one correction that my own experience pushes me to make. I agree that relational understanding must be the goal, and that for the teacher it is non-negotiable: only someone who holds the map can decide, knowingly, when a shortcut is worth giving. I am less convinced that instrumental and relational mathematics are two separate subjects. Many of my students, and I, first walked a route as a fixed plan and only later saw where it sat on the map. Fluency sometimes freed up the mental space to ask why. Skemp also admits that instrumental success restores confidence. For a Pakistani student whose family’s hopes ride on school district board exam results, that confidence is no small thing. In my view, the danger is not the rule; it is the rule that never gets connected to anything. In my BC classroom, I want every procedure to come with its “why,” even if the “why” arrives a week later. I also want to assess in ways that show me which walker is in front of me: asking students to explain their thinking, to predict where a method will break, and to find the error in a worked solution. If marks on paper cannot reveal the map, then conversation and reasoning must count as evidence too. Skemp gave me a name for something I watched for years. The real work now is building classrooms where “I understand” means the same thing to my students as it does to me.
No comments:
Post a Comment