My favourite mathematics teacher taught me statistics in my first year of undergrad in 1999 in Pakistan. I still remember how his classroom felt before I remember anything he taught. It was warm, friendly, and respectful. When we asked a question, he treated it as if it mattered, and slowly we began to believe that our confusion was worth something. He was creative and knew his subject deeply, so he could make a hard idea look simple, often by connecting it to something from our daily lives. Looking back, I notice something beautiful: statistics is the study of variation and error, and he treated our mistakes the same way. A wrong answer was not something to hide but something to look at closely and learn from. He also kept asking, “Is there another way?” That question told us he trusted our minds and believed in our perseverance. And he saw each of us as a different learner, not as one class to get through a syllabus. He not only taught me statistics but also inspired me to pursue the dream that I was someone who could do mathematics. In his class, I felt I belonged in mathematics.
My least favourite mathematics teacher was my grade 8 maths teacher, who created the opposite experience. He taught me lessons too, though not the ones he planned. His lessons were dull, and he showed little kindness or care for his students, so the classroom felt discouraging and none of us felt we belonged there. He lacked competence and honesty and brought no passion or commitment to the subject. Questions were discouraged, and learning meant memorizing questions and formulas for the exam. Mistakes were punished, often with sarcastic and insulting remarks, and his feedback was almost always negative. He never connected a single topic to our lives and showed no love for knowledge or for learning anything new. In his class, I learned to stay quiet, and I learned to fear being wrong. Without saying it, he taught us that mathematics belongs to a few people, and that most of us were not among them.
As a teacher candidate at UBC, what stays with me is that both teachers worked in the same system, with the same exams, the same long syllabus and the same pressures. So, the difference between them was not the system. It was the choices each one made, every day, in small moments: how to respond to a question, what to say after a wrong answer, whether to connect a topic to our lives or just move on. Both covered a syllabus, yet one built confident thinkers and the other anxious, rote learners. This is hopeful, and a little uncomfortable. The difference was not the content but the relationships, the respect and the meaning around it. My favourite teacher showed me that how students feel in a maths classroom shapes what they can learn: belonging, curiosity and a safe place to make mistakes are the conditions for real understanding, not extras. My least favourite teacher showed me how quickly a few careless words can convince a student that mathematics is not for them. My take-away is simple: students may forget the formulas we teach, but they will remember how we made them feel about mathematics, and about themselves.
No comments:
Post a Comment