Monday, October 26, 2026

Group Micro-teaching Reflection

On Wednesday, October 21, Adam, Jarrad, Joe, and I taught a 15-minute Grade 8 lesson on theoretical probability to half of our EDCP 342A class. We built the lesson around two class activities, including one carnival game, “The Lucky Double”: pay $1, flip heads AND roll a 6, win $10, and another game involving rolling three dice at a time to find the probability of a particular sum across all three dice. After a brief introduction, the lesson started with “Which game would you like to play?” to divide the students in half, and every part of the lesson after that was designed to give students the math to answer. Eleven classmates gave us written feedback, and we also assessed ourselves. Here is what I learned.

                                 Average peer ratings (out of 3, from 11 classmates)

What went well

Engagement was our biggest strength. Most ratings for focus, confidence and body language were the top score of 3. Classmates wrote “Very interactive, very cool!”, “Really great lesson! So fun!” and “Loved the carnival games theme!” The hands-on Booth Lab, where pairs flipped coins and rolled dice, worked especially well; one peer said it “gets students going”. I was also glad the math came through. One classmate thought there could be “no way” for content this complicated to be clear, “but it is clear, and even has a lab”. Another noted our “concrete distinction between theoretical and actual probability”, and a third left knowing that “probability is not obvious”. For Grade 8, that is a powerful idea.

What did not go to plan

Honestly, our biggest problem started before we taught. Because we had so little time to meet either virtually or in-person, there was a lack of communication and coordination while we prepared. Each of us built a strong part on our own, but no one owned the full 15 minutes. Together we prepared more material and activities than a 15-minute lesson can hold: 15 slides, a hook video, a lab, two practice problems, and a fair-game challenge. On the day, time management became our main issue. We ran out of time, and our conclusion was too short. Timing received our second-lowest score, including a 1 with the note “Try to conclude in time” and the comment “you tried to cover a lot in 15 minutes”.

Losing the ending hurt more than I expected. Our lesson was a story that began with “Which game would you like to play?” and was meant to end by solving the booth: a 1/12 chance of winning, so the booth keeps about 17¢ of every dollar. Without that ending, the story had no payoff. I think this is why “learning objectives met” was our lowest score, why one peer “lost track of the learning objective along the way”. Our own self-assessments agreed: we had fun, but we were not sure the objectives were fully met. Two more comments made me think. Classmates suggested we could build on earlier learning (“as we saw last class”) instead of re-teaching every term. And one warned, half-joking, “Be careful turning kids into gamblers!” A money game is a great hook, but I must frame it as a lesson about how games are designed so the house wins, not as an invitation to play.

In my own part, Four Ways to See a Sample Space, I explained set notation and a tree diagram and showed a table and a Venn diagram in under four minutes. Looking back, that was a lot. The curriculum names tree diagrams and tables; teaching those two deeply while saving the set notation and Venn diagram for another day might have taught more.

Lessons for my future teaching
  1. Plan less, teach deeper. A short lesson needs one clear goal. I will sort content into “must know” and “nice to have” and keep the second as an extension.
  2. Protect the closure. When time runs short, cut from the middle, never from the end. The closing is where learning comes together.
  3. Rehearse with a timer. One full run-through would have shown us the problem before our classmates did.
  4. Communicate early when co-teaching. Agree on the objective and the timing first, then build one shared plan with one timekeeper.
  5. Keep the objective visible. Return to it during the lesson and bring the whole class together to discuss problems, as one peer suggested.
Our carnival booth was fun, but, like the game itself, the odds were against us from the start: too much content and too little time. Next time, we will plan the 15 minutes before I plan the slides.


                            















Saturday, October 17, 2026

Individual Micro-teaching Reflection

 

  



On October 14, I taught my first individual micro-teaching lesson in EDCP 342A, Curriculum and Instruction in Secondary Mathematics. The lesson was non-curricular, so I chose something I love: footwork in singles badminton. In ten minutes, I wanted my peers to name the six corners of the court, practise the sequence: ready → split → lunge → recover, and notice a little mathematics hiding inside the movement. I opened with a 60-second animated video, “The 60-Second Footwork Challenge,” then moved through a short explanation, a demonstration, a volunteer practice, and a quick fist-to-five check. Afterwards, four peers and I filled in a feedback form. This is what I learned.

What went well

The strongest message from my peers was about engagement. One peer called the lesson “very high-energy and enjoyable”. Another said my passion and “great teacher voice” made it really engaging, and a third described me as “very clear, confident, and informative”. Almost every rating was a 3 out of 3. I learned that energy is not a small thing: when the teacher clearly cares, learners lean in. The hook also did its job. A peer appreciated “the video at the beginning and how the students were led to understand it”. It gave everyone something to do from the first second (watch, predict, shout) instead of only listening.

Where I can grow
  1. Frame before showing. One peer suggested explaining the video a little before playing it, and another asked for “more of an overview at the start”. These two comments point to the same lesson. I knew what the video was for, so it felt obvious to me, but my learners did not. One sentence, such as “Watch the player, count the corners, and be ready to shout the next one,” would have turned a surprise into a purpose.
  2. Invite questions. A peer reminded me to “ask if there are any questions”. In a tight ten minutes, I kept moving forward and forgot to stop and invite the learners in. A question check is not lost time; it is the moment I find out what they actually understood.
  3. Protect practice time. In my own self-assessment, I gave myself a 2 for timing and pacing. My plan gave two minutes to student practice, but explanation and demonstration ran long, so practice felt short. Skills are learned by doing, not by watching the teacher do.
My takeaways for the math classroom
  • A hook needs a frame. A great visual is powerful only when learners know what to look for. Before I show a graph, a pattern, or a video, I will tell students what question it helps answer.
  • Plan in minutes, and know what to cut. Next time, I will mark which parts of my plan can shrink if I run late, so practice never gets squeezed.
  • Pause on purpose. I will build a “What questions do you have?” moment into every lesson plan instead of leaving it to chance.
Good footwork in badminton is a cycle: get ready, read the shot, split and lunge, and always recover to the base position. I now see teaching the same way, and my “base position” is my learners. I am grateful to my peer group for their kind, honest, and invaluable feedback, and I am excited to bring these lessons into my next one.


Monday, October 12, 2026

Feedback To Malihe on Her Workshop on Iranian Immigrant Math Students

Malihe opened her talk with a question I did not expect: what happens when a Canadian family moves to Iran and tries to enrol their child in school, or find a sport or music teacher? As we imagined it, the difficulties piled up quickly: application forms in an unfamiliar script, a different calendar, unwritten rules about who to ask and how. Then Malihe turned the question around, and that shift in perspective was the most valuable part of the session for me. An Iranian family arriving in BC faces the same disorientation in reverse. Parents must make sense of catchment areas, online registration, transcripts that need translating and dates written in the Persian calendar, and a grade placement that may not match what their child had completed at home. Even a report card can be confusing, because a family used to marks out of 20 now receives descriptive proficiency scales. None of this is a problem of ability; it is a problem of navigating a system whose logic is invisible to newcomers.

For the students themselves, the differences reach right into the mathematics. Many Iranian students arrive with strong procedural skills, built in a centralized, exam-focused system that values speed, accuracy and practice, and they then meet a BC curriculum that asks them to explain their thinking, work in groups and investigate open-ended problems. Language adds another layer. Persian is written from right to left while numbers run left to right, Persian digits look different, and the Persian decimal separator resembles a slash, so a number like 2.5 can be confused with a fraction. A student may still do mental arithmetic in Persian while being asked to justify their reasoning in English. Even “real-life” word problems are not culturally neutral: a question about hockey statistics or Thanksgiving recipes assumes everyday knowledge that a newcomer may not yet have, so the real difficulty can be the context rather than the mathematics.

Malihe’s grounding of her research in cultural sustainability and social justice helped me see these challenges as questions of equity, not just adjustment. When newcomer students, whether from Iran, Afghanistan, Syria, Ukraine or elsewhere, are placed in lower math courses because of their English, or judged by their unfamiliarity with classroom discussion, the system can quietly turn a language difference into a mathematics deficit. That label can follow them for years and narrow the pathways open to them. Social justice education asks us to notice whose knowledge counts in our classrooms and to remove barriers rather than expect students to overcome them alone. In mathematics, that means assessing understanding separately from English fluency and making sure that being new to Canada never limits how far a student can go.

What I take from Malihe’s talk is that a newcomer student’s struggle in math class is often a mismatch of systems rather than a gap in understanding. As a future teacher, I want to treat students’ first languages and earlier methods as resources: invite them to show how they learned a procedure, allow them to think in Persian before explaining in English, check notation before assuming an error, and choose real-life contexts that draw on students’ own experiences. I also want to communicate with parents in ways that make the BC system visible rather than assumed. Thank you, Malihe, for helping us see our future classrooms through the eyes of the families who are newest to them.


Math/Art Project: Individual Reflection

When our group first chose Tom Verhoeff’s “⟩Dear⟩ ⟩Cor⟩, ⟨Always⟨ ⟨Busy⟨,” I expected a pleasant but fairly contained project: decode the pattern, reproduce the poem, explain the algorithm. It turned out to be something quite different. The first surprise was how much mathematics was hiding in plain sight. The angle brackets in the title, which I had read as typographic decoration, turned out to record the starting state of Even’s algorithm, and the “sizes/ranks” that drive the algorithm were written down nowhere; we had to infer them from evidence in the rows, the way a detective reconstructs a sequence of events. That act of reverse-engineering felt closer to genuine mathematical work than much of the mathematics I did as a student, because the question came first and the rules had to be earned. The second surprise came during the presentation itself. I had prepared to explain the three rules carefully, but the moment that mattered was when classmates started thinking about the blank rows of the activity table, especially row 13, where a less obvious turn in the sequence sent groups back to check their own reasoning. The third surprise was how the same 24 arrangements opened into entirely different worlds once Mahnaz asked whether each one was even or odd and Malik asked which ones were the same necklace. One collection of objects, three questions, three artworks: I learned that in mathematics the question is the lens, and changing the lens changes what there is to see.

Would I bring this into my own classroom? Without hesitation, and not only in Grade 12, where it maps neatly onto permutations, factorials, probability, and algorithmic thinking. With three students’ names instead of four words, the same idea becomes an entry point for much younger learners, and inviting students to build poems from their own names, or from words in their home languages, would let them see themselves inside the mathematics rather than outside it. What I would protect most carefully is the order of experience: puzzle first, patterns noticed and named by the students, formulas only once they feel the need for a shortcut. Otherwise, a rich task collapses into a rule-following worksheet, which is exactly the instrumental understanding our conclusion warned against. My deepest realization concerns the relationship between beauty and correctness. In Verhoeff’s piece, the ribbons cross only their neighbours because each step is a single adjacent swap; the elegance of the image is the visible proof that the mathematics holds. Art, in this sense, is not a decoration added to mathematics to make it pleasing to the eyes, but a way of making structure perceptible, and perception is where understanding begins. As a future teacher, this shifts how I see my role: less as the person who explains the rules clearly, and more as the person who designs the moments in which students notice them for themselves.

 

Math/Art Project: Reproduction and Extension of Tom Verhoeff's Dear Cor Always Busy

This is a collaborative post written by Izhar, Mahnaz, and Malik.

The artwork we chose

We chose Tom Verhoeff's Dear Cor Always Busy from the Bridges 2026 Math Art Gallery. The piece arranges the four words Dear, Cor, Always, Busy in all 

4!=24

4!=24 possible orders, each word given its own colour. It looks like a poem, but every row is determined by a systematic rule.

Our Reproduction

We reproduced the artwork by building it from scratch in LaTeX. We used the same four words, the same four colours (Dear = green, Cor = yellow, Always = blue, Busy = pink), and the same alphabetical ordering of the 24 rows. Reproducing the piece by hand taught us how easy it is to repeat a row or skip one, which is exactly why a systematic method is needed.

Our Extension

We extended the artwork in two directions, asking two questions the original does not ask:

Parity. If we count the number of inversions in each arrangement (pairs of letters that are out of alphabetical order), we can colour each row by whether its inversion count is even or odd. The result is a perfect 12/12 split, a visual checkerboard with surprising depth.

Necklaces. If we imagine the four words written around a circle, then many of the 24 linear arrangements are the same circular arrangement read from a different starting point. Grouping the 24 rows into these families gives exactly 6 necklaces, each containing 4 rows. We rendered this as a circular mandala in which each colour joins the 4 rotations of one necklace.

The reproduction and the two extensions now live together as a diptych: the linear list on one side, the circular mandala on the other, and the parity colouring as a parallel lens.



Class Activity: Completing the Missing Rows in Traversing the Even’s Algorithm

The class activity asks our classmates to step inside the artwork rather than admire it from the outside. By leaving rows 5–8 and row 13 blank between completed rows, we turn the table into a series of checkpoints: each group can test their reasoning and understanding against the rows we have given. We chose not to walk through the missing rows in advance, because we want the pattern to emerge through discussion. The moment a group notices Dear's back-and-forth sweep is, we think, the moment the algorithm stops being a list of rules and becomes a structure they can predict. Row 13 is the real test of understanding, since it follows a less obvious turn in the sequence. We expect some productive disagreement within groups, and we are curious whether the colour-coded words, like the ribbons in Verhoeff's piece, make the underlying mathematics easier to see. Where groups stall, what they argue about and what they notice first will tell us how well visual art can make an abstract algorithm tangible.












Battleground Schools Reflection

 I used to think of mathematics as the one school subject that stays calm and neutral. Two plus two is four everywhere, so what is there to fight about? Dr. Gerofsky’s history of the last hundred years in North America showed me how wrong that was. Progressivism, the New Math, and the “Math Wars” were all battles over mathematics, and each was really a battle over something bigger. Three moments made me put the reading down and think.

1.  The fight is not really about mathematics

Gerofsky writes that these arguments, “ostensibly over details of mathematics teaching and learning,” are often about “the democratization of education, and views on authority and obedience.” Her table of conservative and progressive views made this very clear. In one column, the goal is “obedience,” mathematics is “authoritative, permanent, and infallible,” and the teacher is “the conduit for the delivery of approved curriculum.” In the other, the goal is original thinking, mathematics is “exploratory and evolving,” and the teacher is an expert designer of learning. Reading it, I realized that my own schooling in Pakistan sat almost entirely in the first column. Nobody had ever told me it was a position. It was simply what “maths” meant. Seeing it as one choice among others felt freeing. I was also grateful that Gerofsky warns these dichotomies are “perhaps falsely exaggerated.” Few progressives are against fluency, and few conservatives are against understanding. The real work happens in the middle, and the shouting from both sides makes that middle harder to find.

2.  Teachers who succeeded, and those who never did

This was the most personal stop. Gerofsky describes two kinds of teachers who keep traditional maths in place. The first are math-phobic teachers who “got by” memorizing procedures and pass their fear on. The second are those who thrived in orderly, drill-based classrooms and expect everyone else to succeed the same way, so that anyone who struggles “may be written off as not meant to do math in the first place.” I recognized myself in that second group, and it made me uncomfortable. The system worked for me. That is exactly why I have to be careful, because my success is not proof that the method works for everyone. It may only prove that it worked for people like me. I was also struck by her point that society attaches “no shame, and lots of positive social valuation” to saying “I can’t do math.” Nobody proudly says “I can’t read.” That small difference tells us a lot about who we think mathematics is for.

3.  A curriculum exported without listening

The New Math section stopped me as someone who learned mathematics outside North America. After Sputnik, “jet-setting curriculum developers” carried highly abstract, Western materials to developing countries and “showed little regard for local conditions, cultures, or educational traditions.” One detail almost made me laugh: the Bourbaki mathematicians who inspired this movement wanted to ban diagrams and drop the teaching of geometry. It shows how far a curriculum can drift from real learners when it is built around experts’ ideals. It also made me wonder how much of the mathematics I was taught in Pakistan was shaped by decisions made far away, for reasons that had little to do with us. Now I am the one crossing borders, so I carry the opposite responsibility: to listen to my students, their communities, and their ways of knowing before assuming that what I bring is what they need.

What I take with me

Across all three movements, reform followed a shock from outside the classroom: industrialization and war, Sputnik, and a disappointing TIMSS ranking. Often the driving feeling was fear of falling behind. Fear produces loud debates and quick fixes, but it rarely produces good classrooms. Knowing this history will not end the Math Wars. It may, however, help me notice when I am being pulled into one side, and help me remember that beneath every curriculum debate is a quieter question: who is mathematics for, and who gets to decide?


Eisner Reading Reflection

 My first thought: curriculum as a racetrack

If you had asked me a few weeks ago what “curriculum” means, I would have pointed to a document: the list of topics, the textbook and the exam paper at the end. That is how I lived it in Pakistan. The curriculum was the book we had to “cover” before the board exam, and a good teacher was the one who finished it on time. The word comes from the Latin currere, “to run,” and for me it really was a racetrack: a fixed path, a finish line and very little time to look around. In this picture, the curriculum is something written by others far away, delivered by teachers and received by students. Eisner’s chapter quietly took that picture apart.

Three things that made me stop

1. “The timetable teaches.”

Eisner writes that schools teach “because of the kind of place” they are. The bell, the 50-minute period, the rule that you speak only when called on, and the desks that “yield to no form of body pressure” all carry lessons that no syllabus lists. This made me stop because I suddenly saw the implicit curriculum of my own maths classrooms. Yes, we learned algebra. Underneath it, we also learned that the teacher holds the answer and the student waits for it, that being fast means being smart, that every problem has exactly one correct method, and that a good student is a quiet one. Nobody wrote these lessons down, yet I carried them for years. I now wonder whether my students will remember the quadratic formula longer than they remember what my classroom taught them about who gets to speak in mathematics.

2.  The arts on Friday afternoon

Eisner notices that the arts are usually taught on Friday afternoons, after the “real work” of the week is done. Nobody announces that art is unimportant; the timetable says it for them. I immediately thought of the way maths is often taught in Pakistan. Exploration, puzzles and open problems such as the Locker Problem tend to arrive at the end of a unit, “if we have time.” Practice worksheets and tests arrive on schedule. Students read that code very clearly. They learn that critical and creative thinking is a treat and rote learning, worksheets, and repetitive exercises for standardized tests are the real jobs. The question I heard most often from my own students was, “Is this topic important and will this be on the exam?” Eisner helped me see that this question is not laziness. It is a student reading the implicit curriculum correctly.

3. “Ignorance is not simply a neutral void.”

The idea of a null curriculum, the things schools do not teach, was the biggest stop for me. Eisner argues that what is left out shapes the options a person can even imagine. He also points to a narrowing of thinking itself: school treats “cognition” as thinking with words and numbers, and leaves out visual, metaphoric and intuitive ways of knowing. This is a strong criticism of how mathematics is often taught, because mathematics is deeply visual and imaginative. When we reduce it to symbol manipulation, the null curriculum sits inside the maths lesson. Looking back, my own school mathematics left out much more than it taught: estimation, questioning data, the history and human stories behind the ideas, and the simple experience of wondering about a pattern. Eisner names economics as part of the null curriculum, and I recognized that too. I learned compound interest as a formula, never as a way to understand a loan my family might take.

How Eisner expands the idea of curriculum

After reading Eisner, I no longer think of curriculum as a document. I think of it as everything students experience, and everything they are denied. There is the course as it is written, the course as it is actually lived in the room, and the course that never appears at all. All three are present in every lesson. This changes my role. I am not simply delivering a curriculum someone else designed. Through my tone, my seating plan, the questions I ask, what I do with a wrong answer and what I choose to give time to, I am making curriculum every day, whether I mean to or not. Like the implicit lessons Eisner describes, this happens mostly without anyone noticing, so the first responsibility of a teacher is to notice.

Where the BC curriculum meets Eisner

The redesigned BC curriculum seems to bring some of Eisner’s hidden curricula into the open. Its Know–Do–Understand model, Curricular Competencies (reasoning, communicating, connecting and reflecting) and Core Competencies turn what used to be implicit lessons into explicit goals. The First Peoples Principles of Learning and financial literacy begin to fill parts of the old null curriculum. Still, Eisner’s chapter also warns me not to be too comfortable. A provincial document can mandate the explicit curriculum, but not the implicit one. That part lives in my classroom, so I want to read the BC curriculum the way Eisner reads a school: for what it says, and for what it leaves unsaid.



Sunday, October 11, 2026

The Locker Problem

The puzzle

A school has 1,000 students and 1,000 lockers, and every locker starts open. Student 1 closes every locker. Student 2 changes every 2nd locker, student 3 changes every 3rd locker, and so on until student 1,000 has had a turn. Which lockers end up open, which end up closed, and why?

How I worked on it

My first thought was honest panic: 1,000 students and 1,000 lockers is far too much to track in my head. So, I did what I would want my students to do and made the problem smaller. I drew ten boxes on paper and acted out the first ten students, crossing and uncrossing as I went. After a few rounds, I noticed that each student only changes lockers that are multiples of their own number. That changed the question. Instead of following students, I could follow a single locker. Locker 12 is changed by students 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 12. These are exactly the divisors of 12.

I then took my first wrong turn. Lockers 2, 3, 5 and 7 were all open, so I guessed that the primes stay open. However, locker 6 broke that idea straight away, because it is open but not prime. So, I stopped guessing and made the following table to dig further.

Highlighted (pink) rows are the lockers that end up closed.


The above table shows a clear pattern. The closed lockers are 1, 4, 9 and 16, the perfect squares (1 = 1², 4 = 2², 9 = 3², 16 = 4²). They are also the only lockers changed an odd number of times.

Who changes each locker?

From the table above, we can see that a student changes a locker only when the student's number divides the locker number exactly. In other words, the students who affect a locker are the factors of that locker number.

Why are perfect squares different?

Let us take an example of locker 16.

The factors of 16 are 1, 2, 4, 8 and 16.

We can pair 1 × 16 and 2 × 8, but the middle factor is 4 × 4.

Because 4 pairs with itself, locker 16 has 5 factors, an odd number. An odd number of changes makes a locker that started open finish CLOSED.

This is the key idea: most numbers have factors in pairs, but a perfect square has one unpaired factor — its square root. Therefore, only perfect-square lockers have an odd number of factors.

Now, I will find all perfect squares up to 1,000

We need the square numbers from 1² upward. As a simple estimate, 30² = 900; so, 31² = 961, but 32² = 1,024; there are exactly 31 perfect squares between 1 and 1,000.

1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49, 64, 81, 100, 121, 144, 169, 196, 225, 256, 289, 324, 361, 400, 441, 484, 529, 576, 625, 676, 729, 784, 841, 900, 961.

Why it works

Each locker starts open, so an even number of changes brings it back to open, and an odd number leaves it closed. The real question is therefore: which numbers have an odd number of divisors? Divisors usually come in pairs. For 12, these are 1 × 12, 2 × 6 and 3 × 4, giving six divisors, an even number. However, a perfect square breaks the pattern because one divisor pairs with itself. For 16, the pairs are 1 × 16, 2 × 8 and then 4 × 4, where the 4 is counted only once. That leaves an odd number of divisors, five.

Answer: The 31 perfect-square lockers (1, 4, 9, 16, … 961) are closed, and the other 969 (1,000 – 31) lockers are open. There are 31 because 31² = 961 is the largest perfect square below 1,000, since 32² = 1,024 is too big. I also checked this by simulating all 1,000 students with a short computer program.

Final Answer

Number of Closed lockers: the 31 perfect-square lockers listed above.

Number of Open lockers: 1,000 − 31 = 969.

Why?

Non-square numbers have factors in pairs, so they are changed an even number of times and finish OPEN. Perfect squares have an odd number of factors because their square root is paired with itself, so they are changed an odd number of times and finish CLOSED.

Taking it into the classroom

I would not start with numbers. I would start by acting it out, with 20 students standing in a row, each holding a card showing “open” on one side and “closed” on the other, while other students take turns flipping them. A physical experience makes the pattern something students see before they can explain it. From there, a few extension questions can lead them deeper into number theory:

  • Which lockers are changed exactly twice? These are the primes, so students arrive at a definition of prime numbers through their own work.
  • Which lockers are changed exactly three times? These are the squares of primes, such as 4, 9, 25 and 49. Why can no other number have exactly three divisors?
  • What if the lockers started closed? What if only students 1 to 500 take a turn? Changing one condition and predicting the result before testing it is where real understanding shows.
  • Can you prove it? Explaining the divisor-pairing argument to a partner, in words or with a picture, is a first step into mathematical proof.

What I am taking away

What I value most about this problem is that it rewards curiosity more than speed. My first strategies were small cases, drawing, a table and a wrong conjecture that I had to give up. These are not signs of weakness. They are what doing mathematics actually looks like. In many of my own school experiences, the steps towards an answer were hidden, and only the final answer counted. With problems like this one, I want my students to see that a crossed-out guess is part of the work, not a failure. The lockers are simply a way in. What I hope my students take with them is the habit of asking, “Why does this pattern happen?”

Another takeaway: One small detail surprised me. In the usual version of this puzzle, the lockers start closed, so the squares are the ones left open. Here the starting state is reversed, so does the answer. The maths is identical, but a student who has memorized “the squares are open” would get this question wrong. This is Skemp’s instrumental vs. relational understanding in a single puzzle. Only the student who knows why the squares behave differently can adapt to the change.



 



Two Teachers, Two Lessons: The Maths Classrooms That Shaped Me

My favourite mathematics teacher taught me statistics in my first year of undergrad in 1999 in Pakistan. I still remember how his classroom felt before I remember anything he taught. It was warm, friendly, and respectful. When we asked a question, he treated it as if it mattered, and slowly we began to believe that our confusion was worth something. He was creative and knew his subject deeply, so he could make a hard idea look simple, often by connecting it to something from our daily lives. Looking back, I notice something beautiful: statistics is the study of variation and error, and he treated our mistakes the same way. A wrong answer was not something to hide but something to look at closely and learn from. He also kept asking, “Is there another way?” That question told us he trusted our minds and believed in our perseverance. And he saw each of us as a different learner, not as one class to get through a syllabus. He not only taught me statistics but also inspired me to pursue the dream that I was someone who could do mathematics. In his class, I felt I belonged in mathematics.

My least favourite mathematics teacher was my grade 8 maths teacher, who created the opposite experience. He taught me lessons too, though not the ones he planned. His lessons were dull, and he showed little kindness or care for his students, so the classroom felt discouraging and none of us felt we belonged there. He lacked competence and honesty and brought no passion or commitment to the subject. Questions were discouraged, and learning meant memorizing questions and formulas for the exam. Mistakes were punished, often with sarcastic and insulting remarks, and his feedback was almost always negative. He never connected a single topic to our lives and showed no love for knowledge or for learning anything new. In his class, I learned to stay quiet, and I learned to fear being wrong. Without saying it, he taught us that mathematics belongs to a few people, and that most of us were not among them.

As a teacher candidate at UBC, what stays with me is that both teachers worked in the same system, with the same exams, the same long syllabus and the same pressures. So, the difference between them was not the system. It was the choices each one made, every day, in small moments: how to respond to a question, what to say after a wrong answer, whether to connect a topic to our lives or just move on. Both covered a syllabus, yet one built confident thinkers and the other anxious, rote learners. This is hopeful, and a little uncomfortable. The difference was not the content but the relationships, the respect and the meaning around it. My favourite teacher showed me that how students feel in a maths classroom shapes what they can learn: belonging, curiosity and a safe place to make mistakes are the conditions for real understanding, not extras. My least favourite teacher showed me how quickly a few careless words can convince a student that mathematics is not for them. My take-away is simple: students may forget the formulas we teach, but they will remember how we made them feel about mathematics, and about themselves.

Skemp Article Response


The first thing that made me stop was not an argument but a child’s reply: “Of course I do. Look, I’ve got all these answers right.” I have heard that sentence many times, in English and in Urdu. When a student in Pakistan told me “samajh aa gaya” (“I’ve understood”), I rarely questioned it, because the school board examination asked the kinds of questions the textbook had already trained them for. Skemp’s idea of faux amis showed me that my students and I were using one word for two different things. More uncomfortably, I had once been one of those students. My own schooling rewarded faithfully reproducing a solved example, and for years I thought I understood mathematics because I could perform it. 

The second thing that stopped me was the head of mathematics, who told his class to write their answers “exactly like the example in the book.” I smiled at first, then recognized the move. When a marking scheme decides grades, and the syllabus must be “covered” before exams, the model answer quietly becomes the curriculum. Skemp’s line, “nothing else but relational understanding can ever be adequate for a teacher,” names a cycle I know well. Teachers who were taught instrumentally go on to teach instrumentally. This is not laziness. Instrumental understanding is simply all the system ever asked of them.
The third moment, and the one that has stayed with me most, was Skemp’s image of the town: a walker following fixed plans and a walker building a mental map. From the outside, he says, the two look identical. That is exactly why an exam script cannot tell you which kind of learner wrote it. I saw the difference most clearly while teaching programming rather than mathematics. Students who had memorized a loop or a recursive function could reproduce it perfectly. But the moment the program threw an error, they were lost, because a fixed plan offers no way back after a wrong turn. Students who had a map treated the programming bug as information: they knew where they were, so they could work out what had gone wrong. I now think debugging may be the purest everyday test of relational understanding. Discrete mathematics showed me the same thing. A student who has learned proof by induction as a three-step template can prove that 1 + 2 + … + n = n (n + 1)/2. Yet the same student freezes when induction is applied to an inequality or a graph, because the template told them what to write and never why the dominoes fall.
So where do I stand? With Skemp, but with one correction that my own experience pushes me to make. I agree that relational understanding must be the goal, and that for the teacher it is non-negotiable: only someone who holds the map can decide, knowingly, when a shortcut is worth giving. I am less convinced that instrumental and relational mathematics are two separate subjects. Many of my students, and I, first walked a route as a fixed plan and only later saw where it sat on the map. Fluency sometimes freed up the mental space to ask why. Skemp also admits that instrumental success restores confidence. For a Pakistani student whose family’s hopes ride on school district board exam results, that confidence is no small thing. In my view, the danger is not the rule; it is the rule that never gets connected to anything. In my BC classroom, I want every procedure to come with its “why,” even if the “why” arrives a week later. I also want to assess in ways that show me which walker is in front of me: asking students to explain their thinking, to predict where a method will break, and to find the error in a worked solution. If marks on paper cannot reveal the map, then conversation and reasoning must count as evidence too. Skemp gave me a name for something I watched for years. The real work now is building classrooms where “I understand” means the same thing to my students as it does to me.

More Top Math Films Review

Anthony Persico’s Mashup Math list, “10 Best Math Movies for All Ages,” suggests these films as a break from tests or some Friday fun. I thi...