Monday, October 12, 2026

Eisner Reading Reflection

 My first thought: curriculum as a racetrack

If you had asked me a few weeks ago what “curriculum” means, I would have pointed to a document: the list of topics, the textbook and the exam paper at the end. That is how I lived it in Pakistan. The curriculum was the book we had to “cover” before the board exam, and a good teacher was the one who finished it on time. The word comes from the Latin currere, “to run,” and for me it really was a racetrack: a fixed path, a finish line and very little time to look around. In this picture, the curriculum is something written by others far away, delivered by teachers and received by students. Eisner’s chapter quietly took that picture apart.

Three things that made me stop

1. “The timetable teaches.”

Eisner writes that schools teach “because of the kind of place” they are. The bell, the 50-minute period, the rule that you speak only when called on, and the desks that “yield to no form of body pressure” all carry lessons that no syllabus lists. This made me stop because I suddenly saw the implicit curriculum of my own maths classrooms. Yes, we learned algebra. Underneath it, we also learned that the teacher holds the answer and the student waits for it, that being fast means being smart, that every problem has exactly one correct method, and that a good student is a quiet one. Nobody wrote these lessons down, yet I carried them for years. I now wonder whether my students will remember the quadratic formula longer than they remember what my classroom taught them about who gets to speak in mathematics.

2.  The arts on Friday afternoon

Eisner notices that the arts are usually taught on Friday afternoons, after the “real work” of the week is done. Nobody announces that art is unimportant; the timetable says it for them. I immediately thought of the way maths is often taught in Pakistan. Exploration, puzzles and open problems such as the Locker Problem tend to arrive at the end of a unit, “if we have time.” Practice worksheets and tests arrive on schedule. Students read that code very clearly. They learn that critical and creative thinking is a treat and rote learning, worksheets, and repetitive exercises for standardized tests are the real jobs. The question I heard most often from my own students was, “Is this topic important and will this be on the exam?” Eisner helped me see that this question is not laziness. It is a student reading the implicit curriculum correctly.

3. “Ignorance is not simply a neutral void.”

The idea of a null curriculum, the things schools do not teach, was the biggest stop for me. Eisner argues that what is left out shapes the options a person can even imagine. He also points to a narrowing of thinking itself: school treats “cognition” as thinking with words and numbers, and leaves out visual, metaphoric and intuitive ways of knowing. This is a strong criticism of how mathematics is often taught, because mathematics is deeply visual and imaginative. When we reduce it to symbol manipulation, the null curriculum sits inside the maths lesson. Looking back, my own school mathematics left out much more than it taught: estimation, questioning data, the history and human stories behind the ideas, and the simple experience of wondering about a pattern. Eisner names economics as part of the null curriculum, and I recognized that too. I learned compound interest as a formula, never as a way to understand a loan my family might take.

How Eisner expands the idea of curriculum

After reading Eisner, I no longer think of curriculum as a document. I think of it as everything students experience, and everything they are denied. There is the course as it is written, the course as it is actually lived in the room, and the course that never appears at all. All three are present in every lesson. This changes my role. I am not simply delivering a curriculum someone else designed. Through my tone, my seating plan, the questions I ask, what I do with a wrong answer and what I choose to give time to, I am making curriculum every day, whether I mean to or not. Like the implicit lessons Eisner describes, this happens mostly without anyone noticing, so the first responsibility of a teacher is to notice.

Where the BC curriculum meets Eisner

The redesigned BC curriculum seems to bring some of Eisner’s hidden curricula into the open. Its Know–Do–Understand model, Curricular Competencies (reasoning, communicating, connecting and reflecting) and Core Competencies turn what used to be implicit lessons into explicit goals. The First Peoples Principles of Learning and financial literacy begin to fill parts of the old null curriculum. Still, Eisner’s chapter also warns me not to be too comfortable. A provincial document can mandate the explicit curriculum, but not the implicit one. That part lives in my classroom, so I want to read the BC curriculum the way Eisner reads a school: for what it says, and for what it leaves unsaid.



No comments:

Post a Comment

More Top Math Films Review

Anthony Persico’s Mashup Math list, “10 Best Math Movies for All Ages,” suggests these films as a break from tests or some Friday fun. I thi...